View original (French)

Nuki Smart Lock Ultra Test: the premium version disappoints

Anonymous user -  
 Bonjour.fr -
Apple Photos Clean Up
Nuki has introduced a premium version of its smart lock, promising a faster, more compact product that is easy to integrate into a smart home environment with Matter and Thread standards. However, this high-end version has certain limitations, including the lack of a USB-C connection, a non-removable battery, and a motor noise considered unpleasant. Additionally, its installation is seen as more complex. In terms of cost, this lock is priced at 349 euros. And what do you think about the evolution of smart locks? Do you believe the high price is justified by the features offered?
Source
0

4 réponses

Réponse 1 / 4
mathojojo
 

I don’t have it yet, but I think this lock is very well thought out. The magnetic connector is not a bad choice, as mentioned in the article. It ensures that no one will yank the cable, or worse, the USB-C connector of the lock, when opening the door from the outside while the lock is charging. Regarding the yellow plastic wheel. Before judging, one should first understand the specifications. If for some reason the locking mechanism is stuck (such as the door not being closed properly), the mechanism will force itself. You’ll be glad if it’s just this easily replaceable wheel that is broken, and not the motor or some other complex component that is hard to access. One can view it as “a fuse.” As for the non-replaceable battery, it’s a shame, that is true, but I suppose it was a necessary compromise for this design.
3
Réponse 2 / 4
Johann
 

Thank you Fabrice for the test. 
The main current problem with the ultra is its availability!

It has been impossible to purchase from the Nuki website since its announced release in December. Even after registering for the club and requesting to be alerted…

Probably waiting for the stocks of the old version to decrease sufficiently so as not to cannibalize it…
0
Réponse 3 / 4
brucine Posted messages 24409 Registration date   Status Membre Last intervention   4 104
 

Hello,

I understand that the trend is to digitalize everything, but I'm not sure I see the point for an individual.

In terms of burglary control, for example, many people have or had a volumetric alarm system.

Isn't this just replacing one problem with another, like the possibility of a failure in its power supply, the connection meant to manage it, or the diversion of this connection or its control means (like the theft of a mobile phone...)?

If it’s meant for a delivery person or a tradesman to enter while we are at work, I also assume that in addition to controlling the opening, we will double it with "old-fashioned" video surveillance to actually check who came in or out?

I know that besides burglary, physical keys remain in a number of these cases, but still...
0
Réponse 4 / 4
Bonjour.fr
 

As always, non-removable batteries are meant to save space and avoid contact issues... it's exactly the same thing with laptops!

And also to avoid replacing it with a counterfeit battery, obviously cheaper and of poor quality, even very poor, even explosive...

The magnetic connector is obviously a safety feature on a mobile device to prevent pulling the connector out when opening or closing the lid during charging... QED!

Apple has understood this well with its magnetic charging connector on all its laptops! Under the name MagSafe.

Why belittle a positive and economical advancement for the customer?
0