Find an effective noise-cancelling headset Solved

Question

Hello, I'm preparing for my baccalaureate this year and I'm having trouble concentrating on my work because I'm very sensitive to noise. I've heard about NoiseGuard headphones (by Sennheiser) or Noise Cancelling (by Logitech), which supposedly emit sounds that are out of phase with external sounds so that they can no longer be heard. My goal is not to listen to calm music, but simply to have perfect silence (around 0dB!), so I bought and tested the SENNHEISER PXC 300, which didn't suit me because it has no effect on a person's voice in a neighboring room, so I am looking for a noise-canceling system much more powerful than that. I'm planning to buy the Logitech this time, but I'm afraid of getting the same result. Does anyone know of a headset with an effective noise-canceling system for perfect silence? Thanks in advance.

keres · Accepted Answer

First, some small information: - 0 dB does not exist unless you are in a space without matter. A very quiet room is around 40 dB (I don't remember the exact numbers, but it's in that range) - The frequency range of spoken voice goes from about 200 Hz to 5000 Hz (it can be a bit lower and a bit higher) - There are several types of hearing protection:  - non-molded earplugs  - molded earplugs  - passive headphones (no electronic components)  - active headphones (reduce constant noises like humming, but not unexpected sounds like a horn)  When you say "Can you hear people's voices when they speak next to you?" It all depends on the level they are speaking at. A person's voice typically ranges between 65-80 dB(A); your headphones (Thunder T3 - https://ecentre.audika.fr/57-bouchons-sur-mesure) attenuate by 36 dB at 8000 Hz, but only by 18.3 dB at 125 Hz (which is very low, by the way), so you will have a voice that varies from 40-55 dB(A), which is already very low (like in a recording studio)... but you might hear it if you concentrate.  As mentioned, you can use two protection systems: plugs + headphones, but be careful, you won’t have 30 + 30 = 60 dB of attenuation. It's more complicated than that.  As for simulating being deaf... it's a bit complicated because this isolation system only isolates sounds coming from the outer ear (tympanic membrane) and not from the inner ear, not to mention the discomfort caused by the headphones...  So that's it for your information... but if it's for an experience, it's better not to use the plugs for hygiene reasons and their poor quality (for non-molded plugs).

SurfAdCom · Answer

Hi User Name, noise-canceling headphones of this type are designed for safety not to filter the frequencies of the human voice, sirens, phones... check out the Logitech presentation here: http://www.presence-pc.com/actualite/Noise-Cancelling-Logitech-12082/  Considering that the same applies to other protections (earplugs, helmets), you just need to find a headset whose attenuation in decibels is maximum in the frequency range covered by the voice that bothers you, knowing that the human voice ranges from 40 (bass) to 1500Hz (treble).  Some examples: https://centre-audition.com/  You can also:  combine protections: earplugs + headset... find a quieter place to work... ask the person to respect your efforts... work on your concentration...   Good luck with your exam!  -bye- >>>

User Name · Answer

Hi and thank you for your quick and clear response. But tell me, the link you gave me for the type of headphones you recommend gives me a list of headphones that seem to be hearing protection for construction sites... What do these headphones actually do, do they simply block out sound by covering the ears, because I noticed that their price is much lower compared to that of the SENNHEISER PXC 300 that I bought... Otherwise, do you have any references for headphones that isolate against human voice frequencies, despite their rarity?

User Name · Answer

Ah, regarding the Logitech, it's not the one from the link you gave me that I was talking about, but this one: https://www.01net.com/actualites/ By the way, what do you think of this headset: http://www.centre-audition.com/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=3_19&products_id=88

SurfAdCom · Answer

That one is far superior in terms of sound insulation: compare the attenuations, but it doesn't have the built-in radio...  http://www.centre-audition.com/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=3_19&products_id=11  I haven't found better...   -bye- >>>

User Name · Answer

Thank you SurfAdCom, and I'm sorry for this question, but before proceeding with the purchase, I would like to know, please, what is the difference between the operation of this type of headset and that of Logitech or Sennheiser, given the significant price difference as well?

SurfAdCom · Answer

This noise-canceling headset is intended for protection only. Its system is passive, meaning it only contains layers of acoustic insulation. It filters all frequencies.  Other headsets, like the Logitech and Sennheiser, are designed for listening to music while reducing ambient noise, to avoid having to turn up the volume to protect the auditory system. These headsets feature an active system: a microphone that picks up external noises and a system that sends an opposing signal to the speakers. This is very effective for noises like explosions, traffic sounds, airplanes, etc., but by design, frequencies corresponding to the human voice, sirens, and phones are poorly or not filtered for safety. This type of headset is therefore not interesting for you if you want to filter out the human voice...   -bye- >>>

User Name · Answer

Alright, thanks to you SurfAdCom for your clear and precise answers, I'm going to go for the headset you recommended. I've made sure, it's indeed the type of headset used by airport employees who guide planes on the runways!

deli · Answer

Hello, we are a training center and one of our trainers is developing a course where participants must not be able to hear anything (simulating being deaf), so it's a bit of the same research as you. Did you find the headphone you needed?

User Name · Answer

Yes, that's the one we've been talking about above! ;)

deli · Answer

Thank you for all these details keres - I will forward them to my colleague.

giogio · Answer

Hello, I followed your discussion closely because I also want the same type of headset, and for those who have followed your exchanges, as a point of information, one question is burning in my mind and I can't wait to ask you: "Deli and SurfAdCom, so what do you think of the headset in the end?" (And by the way, regarding the headset in question, it's not very clear... so if you could clarify it for me...) Thank you in advance, and let me congratulate you for your demonstration of interest!

lms · Answer

What is the most effective headset for blocking out the sound of a radio? (without having to listen to your own music) thank you

Francois · Answer

Hello,  I have been suffering from hyperacusis for several years now. I manage my daily life as best as I can, but tasks like DIY and mowing the lawn are downright torturous :( Generally, when I’m doing DIY, I wear earplugs (molded or not) and/or a passive noise-cancelling headset that I bought at the local hardware store. And sometimes it’s still borderline... The lawn mower is still at 100 dB! Is this headset here:  http://www.centre-audition.com/catalog/product_info.php?cPath=3_19&products_id=11   THE solution, that is, to turn the noise of the lawn mower into the purring of a PC fan? Or am I not going to gain "that much" compared to what I already have? I’m really looking for something effective :/ Price doesn’t matter...  Thanks in advance,  François.

denimon · Answer

check out the SENNHEISER HMEC 350 + BP 04 power supply the microphone will be useless, but the attenuation is 25 to 40 db, it is used in helicopters etc... I had the opportunity to test it in a printing house, and being very close to the press, the residual noise was really very low. Even in a testing lab for helicopter engines (noise >140 db), it was impossible to withstand without headphones because the pain threshold was exceeded across the entire audio band, and wearing this model allowed for almost normal work. In a nearly normal environment, all noises disappear. Only problem, in addition to the already mentioned active noise reduction, it is also passive, and to achieve this, the ear cushions are firmly pressed against the head, so comfort is limited. A+ Denimon

cielbleu · Answer

Hello  I am looking for noise-canceling headphones to block out the (very loud) snoring of the person sleeping next to me.  Can headphones be worn in this case? Earplugs hurt my ears and I have to push them in as much as possible. Is it possible to not hear anything at all?

acoustic · Answer

Hello, I'm a bit late to the party, but anyway... There's the active noise-canceling headset range from TechnoFirst, which is a French manufacturer and the inventor of the active headset. They are called NoiseMaster. They are primarily aimed at the industry and are extremely effective. Here are the links: http://www.technofirst.com/fr/home-technofirst/ http://www.technofirst.com/noisemaster.html  At one point, they also made headsets that were a bit more for the general public... I don't know what the situation is now.  In any case, these headsets combine both active and passive noise cancellation.

zero · Answer

Hello, I am not affected by this condition: hyperacusis; but I have read a lot about it and I wanted to know if there are any ongoing studies to completely eliminate the sound of footsteps or human voices (even our own) or even the slightest noise, such as the rubbing of skin or even a simple sneeze.

kant · Answer

I would like to benefit from a quality noise-canceling headset, so that I can truly isolate myself from the surrounding hustle and bustle. I would like to specify that I have no knowledge of the available equipment. With my muted and anticipatory thanks,

tontonflingueur · Answer

Hello everyone,  Still on this theme: I'm looking for software that would simulate the functioning of noise-cancelling headphones by using the microphone of my computer, calculating the phase inversion, and generating (via software) the anti-noise in my earbuds. This would be useful for working on noisy PCs (like fan noise), for example. In the same vein, if this software system could also work while listening to one of my favorite tracks played on my computer... Thank you for your responses.

oreilles cassées · Answer

Hello,  I’ve read the messages regarding noise-canceling headphones. I would like to know if, in hindsight, you were happy with the purchase of the Bilsom Leightning L3 protection headphones (-30dB). My upstairs neighbors are making a terrible noise: I can’t concentrate to study. Best regards  Jean-Michel

XD · Answer

Hello,  The topic is starting to age, but it's still quite visible on Google, so...  I was also looking for a solution to help me fall asleep a bit better, as even the sound of a car in the distance irritates me in some cases; it’s quite variable and especially annoying. I've even used brainwave generator (or the 80MHz on the radio before) to generate a murmur strong enough to cover the ambient noise. This, of course, does not produce silence, but it helps avoid getting distracted by the sounds. It worked quite well for a solution costing €0 :). We might be able to combine both as well.  Another idea, in certain clinics they use hypnosis during surgical operations to make patients "forget" the pain. Perhaps it's possible to do the same to forget the noise (except for the alarm clock :)). I can't say much more since I'm currently ignorant of the possibilities of this practice. Just an idea like that...  P.S. Without advertising, brainwave generator allows generating brainwaves in stereo to enhance concentration or induce states of tranquility... from what I've tried, it doesn't work for me.

jul13140 · Answer

I know this topic is a bit old, but for those who are currently studying for their baccalaureate and want some peace and quiet, the best recipe is: earplugs + library!

chantal de Québec City · Answer

Please help someone!!!  I live in an apartment block and since the end of February, a condo is being built just a few meters in front of my place and I can't take being woken up very early in the morning because of all the construction noise, trucks, etc... Damn construction site, I'm fed up!! Sorry, but I'm at my wits' end and tired every day, so I ABSOLUTELY NEED a solution! What type of earplugs should I get to sleep? I checked the audiology center's website and I saw 2 types that I think would work for me, but I'm not sure since I don't know anything about dB. The (yellow) single-use Bilsom 303 L earplugs and the Universal Earpad earplugs. So if someone could kindly help me to finally get some sleep!!!!;-) Big Thanks!  Chantal from Quebec City!!!

roro · Answer

Undoubtedly the Bose QuietComfort 15.

benicio · Answer

At BHV, a hard hat for a maximum of €5. You can't do better. You can put your earbuds from your player in your ears underneath.

sam · Answer

Passive noise-cancelling headset combined with earplugs Perfect silence does not exist, for example, human breathing measures around 10 dB... If your work environment is relatively quiet (

Gibouille · Answer

I have the same problem. I managed to get by by mixing two solutions.  At night, I use silicone earplugs molded by a hearing aid specialist (the guy who makes hearing aids).  During the day, I can't wear these plugs because if I wear them for 24 hours, they end up irritating my ear. I can't stand the active noise-canceling headphones because they create a humming sound that makes me nauseous. I opted for closed headphones (passive isolation), but it only works if you still play some music. The first headphones I bought are Sennheiser HD25 (which I’m actually selling), they have great sound and good isolation but are too tight (I have a big head), now I have AKG K271 MK2, which has a more average sound, isolates less well but is more comfortable.  My main problem is that at night my girlfriend snores (and my own snoring also wakes me up), and during the day I work in a room with several computers running continuously, and I feel like I have a hairdryer on my head all the time, which makes it hard to concentrate on programming.

Gibouille · Answer

Otherwise, there’s a really effective thing to use on the dog or even on the owner: http://www.savvysurvivor.com/supplementary/barrett82mod.jpg

dody · Answer

you have to make it up lol

Gibouille · Answer

Active or passive? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ws0WIS5E8uM

arthus · Answer

Noise-canceling headphones only deal with sounds that are sufficiently regular, such as humming (effective when flying), but not with voices or impact noises. The simplest solution for your use (relative silence) is to turn to earplugs.

huibonhoa · Answer

I have a super powerful headset that I managed to get about 40 years ago  I can't tell you where I got it  However, the principle is simple. The collar should be made of a heavy sticky material, covered with fabric, so as not to stick your fingers or face to it   Then there's the issue of the shell. If it's covered inside with this sticky mass, you achieve total silence, except perhaps for someone with perfect hearing, which is not the case for many young people who constantly put a walkman on their heads   If the shell is not covered with this sticky material, you get a very good result with spherical shells, which makes you look like Mickey   Besides that, airport headsets are very good   If not, you can try your luck with Elno in Argenteuil, if you are not too picky about the price

XxdrumsxX · Answer

Hello, I play the drums and because of that, I have ear problems. I tried earplugs, DON'T TRY THEM, they get dirty very quickly, are horrifically expensive, AND don't do anything at all.  Drummer's words.

Max · Answer

I am surprised that people are not talking about the headphones from the French company Technofirst, which discovered this technology 15 years ago. These headphones are used by the French army, the SNCF, etc., and other aerospace companies around the world. This is the so-called ANC technology for noise cancellation to create true silence within the headphones. To learn more... there is now a consumer series at competitive prices. https://energie-verte.blogspot.com/2010/04/casque-anti-bruit.html

didier15 · Answer

I also had noise issues and I'm very sensitive to that  I found a really good noise-cancelling headset  the Bose QC3 is truly impressive, it cuts out a lot of external noise

Seeven · Answer

Hello, I know I'm arriving in 2011, but this kind of topic on the net can last a long time.  My brother listens to music with a lot of bass, and there’s no way to make him understand that even at a volume he considers "low," it's really unpleasant. Especially when you want to be in peace; plus, you have to know that this kind of bass goes through most sounds, so you can’t completely drown it out with music (when you’re in the mood to listen to it).  Is an active headset necessary, or can a passive headset be sufficient to really block out this type of bass frequencies?  It’s worth noting that it’s not as loud as the noise you can hear at Fnac. It’s a series of small, very low *booms* that are extremely irritating... That’s why I doubt the effectiveness of active headsets: they block ambient noises; I imagine that it’s ineffective against low-frequency sounds from music that you hear just enough to think only about it once you’ve heard it...  If I could get some feedback on similar situations or advice.  Thank you in advance.

Gibouille · Answer

After several attempts with different solutions, I moved toward purely passive systems by making a good compromise between insulation and comfort.My solution is a lightweight closed headsetAKG K-271 MKII If the noise is really too loud, I supplement it with molded silicone earplugs that I wear IN ADDITION to the headsethttp://www.earplugstore.com/jbcuearpl.html?_s_icmp=HOMEBAR1_CUSTOM_PLUGS

assadoudou · Answer

Hello,  I needed a noise-cancelling headset mainly to reduce the noise from public transport.  I bought the Tinteo ABA 122  http://www.tinteo.com/casques-audio/casque-audio-nomade/casque-audio-a-reduction-de-bruit-active-tinteo-aba-122/  I relied on the 85% noise reduction claimed by the brand. I'm not an expert to say whether it's true or exaggerated, but in any case, I'm quite satisfied.  I can lower the volume and hear just as well as when I was using a regular headset.  My ears will thank me in a few years!  Plus, it's a French brand, it's nice to buy French from time to time ;)

ranservice · Answer

Hi,  Take a look at this:  http://boutique.berger-levrault.fr/administration/documents-accessoires/accessoires-de-ciblerie/protection-auditive-casques/casque-impact-sport.html

Master54119 · Answer

simple, inexpensive, comfortable and effective (Peltor Optime II or III, I have them and it's to tell you that it reduces noise very significantly and muffles it well, even completely cuts it out. Personally, I think the so-called "active" headphones aren't worth much because they charge exorbitant prices to reduce noise in the same way as the "passive" ones do... buy Peltor because they are comfortable and cover 31 dB and 35 dB and only cost 20 euros... you can sleep with them without worry (Peltor II being less bulky than III). It's up to you to make the choice because the convenience and price are with passive headphones and not active ones, so if you're just looking for silence (awake), you can use Optime III, but if you plan to sleep with them, opt for Optime II instead.

tututuuu · Answer

Hello,  For your information, audio technology is constantly improving and brings new protections, earplugs, high-tech headphones. For example, I’ll tell you about Alvis earplugs that block only harmful noise for the ear without isolating you from the outside world (a little high-tech gem). I recommend checking out this blog linked to a commercial site defining new audio technologies: https://www.audilo.com/175-bouchons-d-oreilles

Find an effective noise-cancelling headset

42 réponses

How to get the character µ on the android keyboard.

Texture issues in enshrouded

Access issue to my "contact me" profile

Windows spotlight is not working.

My tv turns off and then on again repeatedly?

Executable from a python file

Pay in 4 installments cdiscount

The alt gr key is not working on my keyboard.

Code 80072efe how to get windows update working again

Video in ".3gp" format