Time Machine and case sensitivity
DayCay
-
SP -
SP -
Hello,
I would like to know if it poses a problem that my external hard drive on which I do Time Machine is in case-sensitive extended OS (journaled), knowing that my Mac's hard drive is in journaled extended OS?
Thank you
Configuration: Mac OS X / Firefox 5.0.1
I would like to know if it poses a problem that my external hard drive on which I do Time Machine is in case-sensitive extended OS (journaled), knowing that my Mac's hard drive is in journaled extended OS?
Thank you
Configuration: Mac OS X / Firefox 5.0.1
3 answers
Hello,
If you consult this Apple article Mac 1-2-3: Time Machine, there is no problem because Time Machine can handle this format.
A reminder about these two formats:
Mac OS Extended: this is the "understandable" name for HFS+ (Hierarchical File System Plus), a file management system that appeared with Mac OS 8.1 (and still valid on Mac OS X). Improvements made (among others):
- file names are now limited to 255 characters, instead of 31 previously
- file names are encoded in Unicode instead of Macroman: this allows for internationalization of file names
- the maximum file size increases from 2 to the power of 31 bytes to 2 to the power of 63 (more details here)
Journaled: this means that every write on the disk is recorded in a journal. In the event of an unexpected machine crash, the recovery of unwritten data is made easier as a result.
Case-sensitive Mac OS Extended: This format appeared with Intel processors and Mac OS X.4. It is based on HFSX, which is based on HFS+, which in turn is based on HFS. Main improvement: with this option, files named "fred", "Fred", and "FRED" are considered as different files. With the default HFS+, these three files are the same file.
Ritchi
If you consult this Apple article Mac 1-2-3: Time Machine, there is no problem because Time Machine can handle this format.
A reminder about these two formats:
Mac OS Extended: this is the "understandable" name for HFS+ (Hierarchical File System Plus), a file management system that appeared with Mac OS 8.1 (and still valid on Mac OS X). Improvements made (among others):
- file names are now limited to 255 characters, instead of 31 previously
- file names are encoded in Unicode instead of Macroman: this allows for internationalization of file names
- the maximum file size increases from 2 to the power of 31 bytes to 2 to the power of 63 (more details here)
Journaled: this means that every write on the disk is recorded in a journal. In the event of an unexpected machine crash, the recovery of unwritten data is made easier as a result.
Case-sensitive Mac OS Extended: This format appeared with Intel processors and Mac OS X.4. It is based on HFSX, which is based on HFS+, which in turn is based on HFS. Main improvement: with this option, files named "fred", "Fred", and "FRED" are considered as different files. With the default HFS+, these three files are the same file.
Ritchi
carmnader
Be careful with case-sensitive formatting, Adobe applications do not support it (and they are probably not the only ones).
jflo73
Posted messages
1
Status
Member
Thank you for these very precise and useful explanations.
statreal
Thank you for this clear explanation.
SP
Yes, the Mac OS Extended (Case Sensitive) format is a source of errors for many applications; unless you have a very specific need, I do not recommend it.