Intel Core i5 vs Quad-Core Q8300

wywy22 -  
 Anonymous user -
Hello,
I would like to know which of these two processors is the most powerful: Intel Core i5 or Intel Quad-Core Q8300?
Configuration: Windows 7

27 réponses

  • 1
  • 2
r@zer-pro Posted messages 5185 Status Contributeur 478
 
Hi,

"The i5 with 4 cores without hesitation!"

A quad-core also has 4 cores, and that said, a quad-core can prove to be more efficient in terms of frequency and especially in terms of cache memory; an i5 or i7 also only have 8MB and the quad has 12MB of cache, however, it is true that quads will soon disappear.

"LGA1156 socket with 32nm process"

Some i5s have a 45nm process, you need to be careful...

http://img685.imageshack.us/img685/2922/recapitulatifdesi.jpg

Best regards

--
Thank those who take their free time to inform you
       --- I started by learning and I end up teaching---
7
EGP-Swyx Posted messages 7141 Status Contributeur 626
 
After the iX2xxx series, even an i3 is better...
https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu_lookup.php?cpu=Intel+Core2+Quad+Q8300+%40+2.50GHz
https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu_lookup.php?cpu=Intel+Core+i3-2100+%40+3.10GHz
0
Anonymous user
 
His message is from 2010... Think a little before making such remarks.
0
EGP-Swyx Posted messages 7141 Status Contributeur 626
 
I hadn't looked at the date... but who dug up this topic?
0
r@zer-pro Posted messages 5185 Status Contributeur 478
 
Hello,

I’m a little late, but:

a quad can turn out to be better than an i5, in terms of frequency and cache memory, they are currently more performant than i5s. It’s true that quads are outdated and replaced by the new "i" range from Intel, but they still remain more efficient...

Regarding the 8GB of RAM, I find it unnecessary; even 6GB can be fine, but I don’t see the utility of 8GB.

Next, a motherboard for an i5 processor is more upgradable, as you could put in an i7 processor in a year or more, but with a quad motherboard, you cannot.

Check the link from my first post, you will see the range of the new "i", including the i3, i5, i7, and i9.

Best regards,

--
Thank Those Who Take Their Free Time to Inform You
--- I Started By Learning and I End Up Teaching ---
3
Nero15 Posted messages 2657 Registration date   Status Membre Last intervention   104
 
The I5!
--
A geek is someone who believes there are 1024m in 1km.
1
nagrom20 Posted messages 354 Status Membre 33
 
the i5 with 4 cores without hesitation! equipped with QPI and the new LGA1156 socket, manufactured in 32nm, finally so many interesting things!! not to mention that dual and quad will soon disappear from sales ^^

there, I think I've said it all...
1
Nero15 Posted messages 2657 Registration date   Status Membre Last intervention   104
 
"not to mention that dual and quad will soon disappear from the market ^^ "

you mean "core 2" duo/quad ;)
--
A geek is someone who believes there are 1024m in 1km.
1
Soldier7 Posted messages 53 Status Membre 1
 
i5, take into account what r@zer-pro says

a+
1
tofix Posted messages 901 Status Membre 48
 
and +1 for r@zer-pro!!^^
1
nagrom20 Posted messages 354 Status Membre 33
 
Yes, take into account what Razer says. I've outlined the situation, but in the details, choose your i5 carefully. However, I think the two of us have given you the solutions to your problem...
Best regards.
1
r@zer-pro Posted messages 5185 Status Contributeur 478
 
thank you thank you "tofix"

but where is your +1? I don't see it ^^

that said, yes you still need to get an i5_750 socket 1156 because with the motherboard that will go with it (1156) the PC will be more upgradable in the future (personal opinion and advice)

but I see that we all have the same opinion ^^

best regards

--
Thank Those Who Take Their Free Time To Inform You
--- I Started Learning and I End Up Teaching---
1
nagrom20 Posted messages 354 Status Membre 33
 
yes we're tuned in to the same frequency ^^ good luck to you wywy 22 and see you soon on another topic everyone (tofix, razer)
1
r@zer-pro Posted messages 5185 Status Contributeur 478
 
yes good luck to you "wywy22" and see you soon "nagrom20"

best regards

--
Thank Those Who Take Their Free Time To Inform You
--- I Started By Learning and I End Up Teaching ---
1
wywy22
 
Thank you for your response, but the Intel Quad-Core Q8300 is cheaper than the i5.
1
tom
 
Thank you for your response, the price doesn't matter but it's the power that counts. Believe me, I've already tried both CPUs.
0
wywy22
 
Why are quad cores going to disappear? Are they too power-hungry?
1
gttoto Posted messages 1243 Registration date   Status Membre Last intervention   88
 
you can't have it all!!! but the i5 remains the best quality/price ratio at the moment
1
brian johnson Posted messages 1255 Status Membre 153
 
it's the old generation, that's all, but your question is just out of curiosity or are you hesitating to buy? because the socket is not the same...
--
GTA IV won't start? does it give you an error message? is it buggy? well yes... it's GTA IV
1
wywy22
 
I bought a computer with 8 GB of RAM and an Intel Quad Core Q8300, and I would like to know if I made a good choice.
1
gttoto Posted messages 1243 Registration date   Status Membre Last intervention   88
 
Isn't 8GB a bit excessive? And the Q8300 is a shame because it's not very upgradeable, but still, it works well.
0
brian johnson Posted messages 1255 Status Membre 153
 
yes, it still makes for a good PC and you didn't have much choice since it's a socket 775
if you wanted to get an "upgradable" processor, you would have needed to change your motherboard...
--
GTA IV won't launch? is it giving you an error message? is it bugging out? well yeah... it's GTA IV
1
Nero15 Posted messages 2657 Registration date   Status Membre Last intervention   104
 
the i5 750 is also a quad core -_-"
--
A geek is someone who believes there are 1024m in 1km.
1
Anonymous user
 
hi "nero"

who doesn't know that? ^^

however, the i5_6xx only have 2 cores. then you have to choose between the 6xx which have hyper-threading, and higher frequency but less cache memory and a different manufacturing process. you need to choose between all that.

I prefer 4 cores and more cache memory over having higher frequency and hyper-threading.

that's it

@+
1
Nero15 Posted messages 2657 Registration date   Status Membre Last intervention   104
 
no, it's just that you talk about quads as if they were a range, the Core 2 Quad is a quad just like the i7, i5 750, and Phenom II X4!

And then the manufacturing process only serves to reduce consumption, to run cooler, and to be able to fit a lot of stuff in the processor case ^^, performance-wise, 45 or 32 nm is the same thing ;)

HT makes games unstable while the performance gain in compatible software with bi-CPU is quite significant, so it depends on what you want to do with it!
--
A geek is someone who believes that there are 1024m in 1km.
1
  • 1
  • 2