View original (French)

Misunderstanding of the ending of Another Earth - Page 2

Précédent
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
Réponse 21 / 47
romaster
 
Oh yes, you’re right too!!
Wow, what a mysterious ending, it leaves a lot of ambiguity.
I hope there will be a sequel.
Thank you for your participation ;)
0
Réponse 22 / 47
tilitom
 
Yes, sad look I may have gotten a bit carried away, I completely agree it's probably more a look expressing discomfort, a lack of understanding... but that doesn't change my perception of the film and the ending at all.

However, yes, it's clear: there won't be a sequel! And any sequel would be useless.
0
zed pak
 
Rhoda 2 well-dressed, looking happy unlike Rhoda 1 means that on Earth 2 there was no accident, so the Jhone family on Earth 2 is alive and Jhone 1 will be able to see them, and imagine if Jhone 2 on Earth 2 has passed away. This creates a complete ending.

zulfi.pak
0
Réponse 23 / 47
romaster
 
Yes, that's true, but as you said, the frustration is there; no one will ever interpret the same ending, really a shame ^^
0
Réponse 24 / 47
romaster
 
Possible too, but I think we will always have a mixed opinion on this, as a member pointed out, it leaves ambiguity, and especially this great ending that leaves us with this question, you see.
0
Réponse 25 / 47
romaster
 
I thought the same thing as you; in any case, he won't be happy, because either there will have been an accident, or he will see his double with his family.
But as you say so well, it remains an ending to be interpreted by each of us.
0
Réponse 26 / 47
goloum11
 
I just saw the movie.
I was thinking about John1 with John2 and his whole family: complicated
On the other hand, John2 may have come to Earth
Anyway, long live our imagination!
0
Réponse 27 / 47
romaster
 
It also makes sense, but the Johns love their family, because at the moment of the accident, everything changed, and we know that he loves his family.
0
Réponse 28 / 47
melanieg7
 
In the case of the first theory, how would it go for John 1 once he is on Earth 2? Because he would certainly be back with his wife and son (+ daughter), but there would also be John 2, right?
0
Réponse 29 / 47
romaster
 
Yeah, there you go, he would meet his double, or his double would have gone to Earth 1, well there are thousands of possible endings ^^
0
Réponse 30 / 47
romaster
 
Not bad this ending, I hadn't thought about it much!
Well, regarding the idea of killing the other, I find that a bit extreme lol.
0
Réponse 31 / 47
romaster
 
Good evening, you have a very good idea too, I'm on board!
I should watch it again, it might give me an idea.
Thank you for your perspective!
And have a good evening.
0
Réponse 32 / 47
tilitom
 
Well done, Anito... hats off!
Your analysis completely blew me away and yet I had thought a lot about it!

I have no more questions and I also embrace this reasoning.

A big thank you to you for this contribution, which definitely makes this film, which was already beautiful, even more so!
0
Réponse 33 / 47
romaster
 
Too bad, he deleted his message!
0
Réponse 34 / 47
tilitom
 
Not deleted but moved up in the list because it received positive votes. :)
0
Réponse 35 / 47
romaster
 
Oh okay, thanks for the info : )
0
Réponse 36 / 47
georges97 Posted messages 14510 Registration date   Status Contributeur Last intervention   2 899
 
Hello everyone,

Does anyone know if the movie is currently showing in the Paris region? I haven't found a theater screening it. I’m afraid I might have to wait for its DVD release, if that hasn't happened yet.

Best regards
0
Réponse 37 / 47
romaster
 
Thank you Tkof, but in my opinion, you're pushing the subject a bit far; it actually sounds like my French teacher ^^
But everything makes sense.
0
Réponse 38 / 47
tkof Posted messages 36 Status Membre
 
@Romaster: I'm not a French teacher, just a developer (app designer), so imagining combinations is a professional deformation ;-p

We can imagine "a happy end," like "a somewhat less happy ending," but no matter the ending, it doesn't change the message "the choices / the way one looks at oneself" (well, that's my interpretation), it's up to everyone to see what they want ^^
0
Réponse 39 / 47
romaster
 
Oh yeah, I understand better now ^^
Yes, it leaves an ending that everyone is free to imagine.
0
Réponse 40 / 47
toorop
 
Hi movie lovers! In my case, I would think more of an ending where John goes to Earth 2 and sends Rhoda’s double to show Rhoda that everything is fine and that it is indeed a mirror planet... So he has found his wife and child. That's the end of the story.
Then comes the imagination, as well as the percentage of the brain never used!
0
Précédent
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3